by Charles Ferguson-Davie
If you could IPO places, then Greater Manchester would likely be trading at an even greater premium than SpaceX. The region has barely left the news over the last few months, ‘Manchesterism’ has been praised for its contribution to the city’s economic strength and it has helped Andy Burnham become the leading contender to be the next Prime Minister.
One of the many positives to draw from Manchester’s success, which has resulted from a variety of key playmakers, not least the formidable late Sir Howard Bernstein, can be put down to a supportive approach to development and inward investment.
Over the years, Greater Manchester has drawn in a remarkable amount of capital. It is now the largest city-region economy outside London, with gross value added of around £100 billion, with foreign-owned companies alone contributing some £37 billion and employing over 170,000 people. The city region has seen an extraordinary number of major regeneration schemes and the city’s skyscrapers have become a symbol of positive forward momentum.
Manchester has also seen a boom in build-to-rent (BTR) housing. More than 20,000 have now been delivered across Greater Manchester and BTR now accounts for close to a fifth of all the city’s rented homes. London now has c.62,000 completed BTR units but should have many more on a relative basis, especially given the higher house prices in London that make ownership more challenging. Furthermore, whilst London has 42% of BTR homes completed so far in the UK, it has only 24% of the units currently under construction.
In London by comparison it has felt like there has been an ideological opposition to allowing developers the opportunity to make a profit. Excessive affordable housing and other community cost contributions have led to fewer units being developed than could have been the case. The associated loss of the economic benefits of development is now damaging the capital. It is possible for London to turn this around, and for a more pragmatic approach to make sure the fruits of investment can be felt by all parts of the community.
Investment, such as for the regeneration of Lumina Village in Old Trafford where our latest BTR scheme, Podium, is situated, which we delivered in partnership with the Greater Manchester Pension Fund, brings halo effects for the surrounding community that can be extensive.
We were among the first institutional investors to back BTR in the UK, as early as 2012, and much of what followed was in Northern cities. In Liverpool in 2015, we turned a former tax office at Queens Dock into The Keel, one of the country’s first large scale housing projects in our generation designed for rent, and in Manchester we assembled a portfolio of more than a thousand homes through The Trilogy in Castlefield and Duet at MediaCity, as well as delivering The Forge in Newcastle.
The world is a very different place now. But with both our economy and housing delivery under pressure, there are two certainties. The first is that demand for rental housing; whether at discounted social or private market rates, is only going to grow. And the second is that, without a high level of collaboration between government and private capital, the investment this country desperately requires, in housing, energy, transport, data centres and runways, has no chance of succeeding.
When you walk around Manchester, or rather when you take the tram, you realise what a catalyst rapid transit is for community investment and housing delivery. It is a model London has also embraced, with the Elizabeth line being a game changer across its suburbs. So more transport infrastructure investment should be encouraged to catalyse housing investment as well as economic growth. Other barriers to investment also need to be relaxed to ensure development viability and BTR should be embraced as a solution to provide high quality affordable housing for those that live and work in our cities.
Whilst many investors will be dreaming of building cities on Mars, those of us looking closer to home should be thinking about how we can encourage investment into more of our towns, to replicate the success of Manchester and provide the ‘rocket-fuel’ we need for growth.